Hardgainer Myth Busting – Myth #1

MYTH #1: Hardgainers must eat 6 meals per day • Hardgainer Performance Nutrition
Hardgainer Myth Busting • Week 1
Icon: Six meals – plate/clock (Myth 1)

MYTH #1: Hardgainers must eat 6 meals per day

Meal frequency is secondary. What matters are daily calories and protein distribution — 3–4 meals + shakes are enough.

Update: 22 Oct 2025
Notice

This page provides context and guardrails. It is not individual medical, nutrition, or training advice. Suitability and tolerance are individual; for pre-existing conditions, pregnancy/lactation, or medication, consult qualified professionals before making changes.

🪓 The myth

Many hardgainers believe: “The more often I eat, the faster I grow.”
The assumption: More meals → more calories → more growth. That’s old-school broscience — not today’s evidence.

🔍 Why this myth persists

  • Old-school bodybuilding: 6–8 meals were treated like a rule.
  • “Metabolism boost” lore: Frequent eating “boosts” the metabolism (misreading TEF).
  • Catabolism fear: “If I don’t eat every 3 hours, I’ll lose muscle.”

👉 Reality: What matters are maintenance calories + a moderate lean surplus, a smart protein distribution, and consistency.

📊 The facts

  • Frequency ≠ magic lever: 3 vs. 6 meals → same muscle gain when calories & protein match.
  • Thermic Effect of Food: TEF tracks with the amount of energy, not the number of meals.
  • MPS triggers: ~2–3 g leucine per meal → see Leucine Threshold & MPS.
  • Real-life adherence: Fewer, larger meals often make NEAT, digestion & hitting calories easier.

Example:
3 main meals × 35 g protein = 105 g
2 shakes × 25 g protein = 50 g
= 155 g protein/day — ideal for 70–80 kg (≈ 2 g/kg BW).

Notice

“Starter values” and examples are for orientation, not prescriptions. Calibrate with weekly averages (bodyweight, steps, intake) and consider context (job/NEAT/tolerance).

🧪 Practice: plan meals smart

  1. 3–4 anchor meals with 25–40 g protein (leucine trigger) — see glossary.
  2. 1–2 shakes as flexible add-ons (see Food Hygiene for basics).
  3. Control daily calories: estimate maintenance & set a lean surplus; monitor Rate of Gain.
  4. Prioritize training: Provide stimulus → respect SRA; keep volume around MEV.
Safety

If you have symptoms, injuries, or medical conditions, get medical clearance before changing training, sleep, or diet.

📚 Evidence (selected, PubMed)

  • Schoenfeld & Aragon (2018): Protein per meal & daily distribution — practical ranges (0.4–0.55 g/kg/meal). PubMed
  • Schoenfeld, Aragon & Krieger (2015): Meal frequency meta-analysis — no clear advantage of higher frequency when calories/protein equal. PubMed · Journal
  • Moore et al. (2009): Dose–response: ~20–40 g protein post-lifting maximizes MPS (young men context). PubMed
  • Areta et al. (2013): Distribution: 20 g whey every ~3 h > bolus/pulse for sustained MPS. PubMed · PMC
  • Morton et al. (2018): Protein meta-analysis: ~1.6 g/kg/day (up to ~2.2 g/kg) optimizes gains; timing/frequency secondary. PubMed · PMC

🏋️️ What really works

  • 3–4 main meals with protein as the anchor.
  • 1–2 shakes (e.g., oats + whey + banana) as flexible add-ons.
  • Consistency > frequency: the daily total is what matters.
  • Mind digestion: 6 mini-snacks = unnecessary stress.

👉 Also read: Hardgainer Test or What is a Hardgainer?

❓ FAQ: short & clear

“Do I need to eat right after training?” A 1–3 h window is fine — the daily total of MPS triggers matters more.

“Are 2 meals too few?” For many hardgainers, difficult for calories & leucine triggers; 3–4 is the usual sweet spot.

⚡ Conclusion

More meals don’t mean more muscle. What matters:

  • Energy balance (hit a surplus)
  • Protein quality & distribution (2–3 g leucine per meal)
  • Consistency (daily, for months/years)

Your body doesn’t need 6 meals — it needs strategic meals.

MYTH: “Hardgainers need 6 meals a day.”

FACT: 3–4 meals + shakes are plenty.

REMEMBER: Consistency beats frequency.

Notice

Descriptive information for orientation — not a therapy, diet, or training prescription. Consider individual differences and possible contraindications.

🔗 Further reading

A new hardgainer myth every week • More at hardgainerperformance.com • Follow @hardgainerperformance
Read now